بسم الله الرحمن الحيم
With the ‘ism’ of Allah the Most Compassionate the Most Merciful.
Why some Muslims fear and oppose rationality heavily? They claim that Islam isn’t compatible with rationality, because the mind of a human is limited. They further claim that the only way to be ‘safe’ is only by following their religious scholars, not by rationality.
Don’t they read the Qur’an? Don’t they know that Allah told that His signs are for those who give thought, those of knowledge, people who listen, and for people who use reason (Qur’an, 30:21-24)?
In addition, Allah expressed to us that the worst creature is the one who do not use reason: “Indeed, the worst of living creatures in the sight of Allah are the deaf and dumb who do not use reason.” (Quran 8:22).
If God doesn’t want us to use our brain, then why God created brain for us? I’m not telling that the human mind is not limited, it is, but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t use our brain.
If Islam is only about following religious authority to be ‘safe’, then we actually have no right to preach Islam to others. This is because non-Muslims also have their own religious authority. If we are telling ourselves that we must follow ulama, but tell the non-Muslims to abandon their ‘ulama’, aren’t we contradicting ourselves?
Despite the numerous times in the Qur’an God said “afala ta’qilun” (then do you not use your reasoning?). “afala tatafakkarun” (then do you not think?) “afala yatadabbarun” (then do they not ponder?), still, there are some Muslims saying that religion and rationality can never coincide.
In fact, only with thinking and rationality can one be a Muslim and Mu’min in the truest sense. That’s why a famous 20th-century Islamic scholar said:
“You say ‘have faith first then you will understand’. My religion [Islam] says ‘use your reason, then you will understand’ .”
Indeed, rationality makes us understand Islam easier, not drives us away. Muhammad Asad was a Jew born in Austria. After his travels to the Middle East and studied about Islam, he converted to Islam and became one of the greatest and respected Islamic scholar in the world.
Islam is not like any other religion. Islam condemns blindly following parents and traditions (Quran, 2:170). Islam opposes following religious scholars blindly (Quran 9:31). Islam opposes following the masses blindly, (Qur’an, 6:116). The only way to know Islam is through scripture and critical thought, along with the aid of religious scholars.
Muslim shouldn’t fear to use rational thought. They should liberate themselves from this prison of mind. If they are really sincere in their quest for truth, then they will be surprised to see how different things will turn out to be from what they feared.
If all these while you’ve not been clear why you accepted Islam, worry not. I recommend you to look at my e-Book “How to find your ‘why’ in Islam” which can help inspire you to find your reasons. You can get it by subscribing to our newsletter, using the form below. Please note though, that guidance comes from Allah, and the best guidance is the His Book (Qur’an).